Rated 5 out of 5 by Topper Feels good, looks great, fits great
These shirts are very soft and comfortable. They look and feel great. The arm lengths are plenty long for my 38" long arms. I now have 7 of these shirts. A while back I got a blue one that was made in Mexico. It didn't fit right and I returned it to Penny's. I recently ordered another one and it was made in the US as all my others and it fits great.
March 24, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by RDassler Insultingly small
I purchased this shirt in XLXT many years ago and loved it. I need the X-Tall length. I returned to buy an identical replacement and noticed right out of the package that the sizing was smaller. One wash and this X-Tall is smaller than a typical Tall from a quality brand.
If you look closely at the photos above. The version in black is the more recent photo- the other photos have been on the site for years. While the models are different people, the other 4 colors appear to have much longer sleeve length than the black version. My experience is that the new shirts are cut like the photo in black- with sleeves that won't hold up after washing.
I can't help but think it's yet another manufacturer cutting corners. Why bother selling an X-Tall shirt when it's plainly obvious you're not providing the extra length that people need?
January 15, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by patsy sweepstakes entry
I did read other reviews that said this product shrunk, I should have listened. My husband is tall, hence purchasing the extra tall size. Sadly the shirt shrunk so much it is halfway up his back. This item was way to expensive to be so poorly constructed.
February 23, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by OldCustomer Shrinks to be useless.
I bought a 3x and washed it when i got it. Its now smaller than a Large.
December 21, 2015